What Purchasing Teams Miss When Comparing Manufacturing Quotes

composite tooling
8 Views

Comparing quotes from various manufacturers for your company’s parts appears to be a straightforward task. Simply place them next to each other and pick the cheapest one – that is all there is to it! The problem is that sometimes the least expensive one proves to be more costly than you think. Some details might have been overlooked in one of the quotes. Common concerns for the purchasing team include low prices, timely delivery, and acceptable quality. While the price is shown at the bottom of the quote, the reality is that there is much more to it. But with the knowledge of what should be considered while comparing quotes, you can make a much more accurate decision.

What Do Purchasing Teams Usually Overlook?

What is very often overlooked in manufacturing quotes are details of what is included in the price. For example, some suppliers offer tooling and inspection in addition to the part itself, while others do not. So if you are comparing a quote that includes all the required elements and a quote without them, the cheaper option might not be the cheapest at all.

Another point is delivery time. No matter how low the price is, it is of no use if the delivery takes weeks and holds back your production process. Make sure to ask for the delivery time of parts and how the supplier manages with delivery delays.

One more point to mention is the quality of the product. If the manufacturer experiences high rejection rates, you will incur costs for reworking parts, replacing them, and conducting extra inspections. So asking for quality certification, such as AS9100 or ISO 9001, and asking for details of inspection of the parts will give you a clear idea of what to expect.

Why Is the Tooling Important?

Tooling costs deserve a closer look when comparing manufacturing quotes. A lower-cost tool may suit a short production run. Conversely, a longer run may justify tooling that can withstand repeated use. Well-designed composite tooling, matched to the material and manufacturing process, can help maintain consistent part dimensions and reduce the need for replacements. Take Aerodine Composites as an example. They understand that good tooling can help their clients to save money in the long run.

Also, it would be reasonable to ask who owns the tooling after the payment is made. In case you change your supplier in the future, you will want to know whether you will be able to take the tooling with you.

How Can Quotes Be Compared Fairly?

The best way to compare quotes is to ensure that all the suppliers quote on the same information. Give them the same drawings, requirements, quantity and delivery time to make sure that you compare quotes equally. Also, if one quote is much cheaper than the others, ask the supplier for the reasons why. Remember that the supplier who asks you questions is likely to provide better parts.

Read More: Utah Asphalt Contractor for Commercial Driveway Installation and Business Access Roads

Considering the total cost of ownership instead of unit price is also an efficient way to make a reasonable choice. It means that you should consider shipping, storage, rework and cost of any delays. Sure, it will take you some time – but it will save money in the long-run.

Conclusion

Comparing manufacturing quotes is much more complicated than finding the smallest number. Purchasing teams that pay attention to the price, ask about the quality and tooling and consider the total cost of ownership will get much better value from their suppliers. To truly benefit from each quote, it is important to see it as the beginning of a discussion rather than the conclusion.

Read More: Charles Spinelli Provides an Introduction to Common Types of Business Insurance

Leave a Reply